Why won’t we vote for each other in the prefect vote?

This will be a quick-ish post on the basics of game theory. However, rather than opting to use the standard ‘Prisoners’ Dilemma’ scenario, I felt a more topical situation would be fitting and will hopefully make for an interesting application of game theory in the real world. Let’s also assume that the vote hasn’t already happened, too.

In a scenario where each candidate can vote for as many other candidates as he wants, the aim of the game for myself is clear: I need to accumulate more votes, whilst it is also preferable if the other candidates score as few votes as possible in comparison. Subsequently, the temptation here is to create ‘vote exchanges’ where two candidates each agree to vote for each other. However, game theory can help explain why the candidates will often (or every time in a purely hypothetical world) not stick to their word.

The first step is to determine ‘payoffs’  for the different outcomes, measuring the utility that the candidate receives following each outcome. In this case, the players shall be Person X and Person Y (unimaginative, I know). The best outcome for X is for him to not vote for Y, but for Y to vote for him, and thus he has an extra vote and is more likely to triumph overall. The next-best outcome is for both applicants to vote for each other. Although the vote is diluted somewhat, it is obviously better for X to have a vote than to not have a vote. Then, it is better if neither candidate votes for each other – this means that while X gains no advantage overall, he at least does not have to face Y having an advantage with respect to the rest of the competition, which occurs in the worst-possible scenario for Person X. Here, he gains no votes whereas, as a result of voting for Y, Y gains a vote.

The utility will work in the exactly the opposite way for Person Y. We can consequently number the outcomes, with 3 being the most preferable outcome and 0 being the worst. The payoff matrix looks like this:

Vote Not Vote
Vote 2,2 0,3
Not Vote 3,0 1,1

Note that Person X’s choices are on the left, while Y’s are at the top. X’s payoff utility is the first number in each box.

Now, if we look at the table the (Vote, Vote) payoff is clearly the most ‘fair’ and ‘economical’, since the combined payoff is the highest of all the outcomes. However, analysing each person’s individual choices can help understand why the (Vote, Vote) outcome will not occur. Assuming X knows for sure that Y will vote for him, here are his options:

Vote
Vote 2,?
Not Vote 3,?

Knowing that Y will vote, X can either vote or not vote. If he votes, his payoff will be just 2, whereas by not voting he can achieve the maximum payoff of 3. Therefore, he will chose ‘Not Vote’ when he knows that Y will vote. Here’s what will also happen if he knows that Y will not vote:

Not Vote
Vote 0,?
Not Vote 1,?

X voting will provide the worst payoff, but he can achieve a better payoff of 1 by voting. As he will, again, choose to not vote, we can call ‘Not Vote’ the strictly dominating strategy for Person X, because it is better for him to not vote, regardless of Person Y’s strategy. The same is true for Person Y – if he knows that X will vote, he will similarly achieve a better payoff by not voting, and if he knows that X will not vote, he will once more achieve a better payoff by also deciding to not vote. ‘Not Vote’ is subsequently his strictly dominating strategy, and as a result the players arrive at the (Not Vote, Not Vote) strategy. This is known as the voting system’s Nash Equilibrium, because neither player has any incentive to deviate from their current strategy. The ‘vote-for-vote’ deal is rendered a waste of time.

Of course, in reality there are other factors to consider. For example, if the candidates are both good friends then they will feel more benefits in voting than not doing so, meaning actual payoffs are different. However, it is interesting to see how game theory can be modelled to explain very relevant, real life phenomena – and, for anyone out there having to vote for other people for a position, never trust someone who promises to vote for you!

What drives demand?

In our economy today, there are two driving forces that contribute to it growth. AD and AS. AS stands for aggregate supply and it indicates the productive capacity of an economy. AD stands for aggregate demand and it shows how much spending is occurring in the economy. The equilibrium between the two curves serves as an indicator for both RNO (real national output) and the price level. A diagram of this is included below:

Governments try to manipulate both AD and AS to achieve the macroeconomic indicators that they desire like growth, low unemployment, desirable inflation rates and international competitiveness. In this article I will explain the components of aggregate demand, one side of the picture.

A simple view

The basic equation for AD is quite simple: AD=C+I+G+(x-m). The C indicates consumption, spending by households. The I indicates investment, spending done by firms. G is government spending and is the easiest way that the government can manipulate AD. The final component is the net export function (x-m) which is spending on exports minus spending on imports. Also known as the current account this can in itself be used to indicate things like international competitiveness. A government can implement policies to alter all of these things to different ends. An increase in investment can increase long run aggregate supply allowing an economy to grow more in the future. Whilst improving your current account can cause depreciation in the value of your currency.

A more complex composition

In practice the equation that was previously mentioned can be expressed in more detail if it’s further broken down. To group all of consumer spending into one is not an accurate interpretation. Instead you can split it into two factors. One is an autonomous base rate of consumption, a level that consumption will not fall below regardless of changes in post tax income. Post tax income is the other determinant. How much a change in income effects peoples consumption is related through a marginal propensity to consume between 0 and 1. Larger propensities to consume mean that by increasing peoples income you will feel a larger effect to consumption. All of this creates the equation:

The line above the first c indicates that it’s autonomous and cannot be changed within the parameters that we are operating in. However even this is slightly simplifying the situation. Disposable income can be separated into net income plus transfers minus taxes. This is all then multiplied by the marginal propensity to consume and added to the autonomous consumption. We have now taken a look at just one aspect of one side of the two curves which are used to predict rates of inflation and output. Already we see that the picture of our economy is an incredibly complex one that can be very difficult to manipulate to the ends that people desire. Unfortunately in the short space that is this blog I feel one aspect is enough for now so i will leave it at the one.

Unemployment the good and the bad.

The amount of people that are unemployed in the UK has dropped by 58,000 from the last quarter to 1.9million , which is 5.8% of the adult working population (unemployment rate) which is lowest its been since mid 2008. so what does all this news mean for UK economy and how is it going to effect daily peoples lives?

When unemployment is low in an economy, it is usually seen as a positive, because it means that their is demand for labour and lower welfare spending. Meaning firms have business, and the likelihood of businesses going redundant is decreased, as people have jobs, hence money to spend at those businesses. Furthermore in the governments eyes it is also a good thing as their is an increase in tax receipts so ultimately meaning more revenue for state and federal governments. Consequently more facilities and improvements will be made to that economy as the government has more revenue. However this can be misleading if the economy already has high amounts of debt, so what could happen is the government will use this money to pay of their debt, and not actually improve anything. In a case like this the standard of living of people doesn’t really go up and the utility of the government may be at risk if this becomes the case.

A low unemployment rate can also increase the economy’s GDP as suggested by a professor “Arthur Okun” whom which i mentioned in a previous article explaining his theory. Which ultimately states that lower unemployment leads to a higher economic growth.

Furthermore in times of low unemployment, workers feel they have more power to demand higher wages because they know they cannot be easily replaced, so potentially an increase in real wages. As a pose to during high unemployment businesses have more bargaining power because both they and their workers are aware of the competition and that replacing workers is easier.

So how can unemployment be good for anyone?

While low unemployment may be ultimately a great thing there is a popular economic theory known as NAIRU, or Non-Accelerating Rate of Unemployment, that suggests when unemployment drops below a certain rate, around 4.3 per cent, it  leads to higher inflation. This is why governments usually consider raising interest rates during periods of low unemployment to stave off inflation. So the only way unemployment is argued to be beneficial, it is to the people who are not unemployed because it everts inflation ,which itself can have damaging effects,

Is the Unemployment Rate Really the Unemployment Rate?

Before I begin, I should add that I’m not really campaigning for a ban of the unemployment rate (although an end to unemployment would be a good idea). However, I do believe that the measures of employment should be re-evaluated in order to create a more transparent way of viewing the economies of the world.

First of all, for obvious reasons it is important to be able to decide what unemployment actually constitutes before delving any further into the topic. Here lies the first pitfall – nobody can really agree on the definition of unemployment. The most widely accepted definition of unemployment is that of the International Labour Organisation (ILO) which is as follows:

Unemployed people are
• without a job, want a job, have actively sought work in the last 4 weeks and are available to
start work in the next 2 weeks, or
• out of work, have found a job and are waiting to start it in the next 2 weeks.

I think it is fair to say that the above definition seems like a reasonable definition of unemployment and while that isn’t incorrect by any means, there are clearly problems even with what is the most popular way of defining those who are jobless. One issue I have arises in the first bullet point where it is stated that, to count as unemployed, someone must have ‘actively sought work in the last 4 weeks’. This does help eliminate retired people who are jobless in essence but not intended to be included in the count, but gives rise to increasing ‘invisible unemployment’. For example, there are always going to many people who, for whatever reason – often disillusionment – who have not bothered or been able to look for a job for a month or longer, but who would still jump at the chance to work.

Rather than further picking apart the ILO definition of unemployment, we should step back and take a look at what unemployment actually is – and what governments claim it to be. I feel it is fair to chart part-time workers as employed but only to an extent. Currently in the UK, somebody undertaking a one hour per week paid training contract counts as being employed. In reality this quite clearly isn’t ‘real’ employment and I would go as far as saying that it is entirely misleading to claim that working for one hour a week on less than the minimum wage is proper employment. Not to mention the fact that there are over 200,000 workers on ‘zero-hour contracts’, a figure which was estimated by the ONS in 2013. Some of these people will often rarely work at all in a month, although technically employed.

WNNarticle-ZimbabweWomenFarmers-Image-UN-MiltonGrant-1991
A Zimbabwean Farmer

Agriculture and the informal economy has always proved to be problematic for a true evaluation of an economy, and it makes it all the more difficult to compare between countries where factors such as agricultural levels differ hugely. Jared did a piece on the state of African economies a short while back, and with ever increasing importance on trying to diagnose and resurrect idle third world economies, measuring unemployment is tricky. This issue is particularly prevalent in Zimbabwe, an economy which is beginning to climb to its feet again after crushing hyperinflation that largely ended in 2009. The CIA World Factbook puts unemployment at 95% according to a 2009 estimate, but other guesses vary wildly. Zimbabwe’s office for national statistics thought unemployment to be just 10.7% in 2011. These discrepancies exists primarily due to a large informal economy being in place with most Zimbabweans in work operating there. Unemployment may also be misleading with many in rural areas living on the edges of subsistence whilst growing food for themselves and consequently no need for an official job. The desire to stabilise and develop the economies for Africa following a prolonged period of GDP decline has been relatively high up the global political agenda, but effective mobilisation can only come with a clear view of third world economies and how they are actually operating – something we don’t currently have.

Ultimately the underlying question is this: what can we actually do? That’s a very difficult question to find a solution for, but it’s clear that governments are largely responsible for the misleading figures. Back in the UK for example, David Cameron claimed in 2012 that the coalition had ‘created’ over 1 million private sector jobs, but in reality a large portion of these new jobs had previously existed in areas such as Education, and were merely reclassified from the public sector to the private sector. Not only that, but other indicators of employment can be easily manipulated by politicians, with a notable example being the ‘claimant count’ which can be influenced to suit political wishes by having the JSA allowance package altered, naturally causing fluctuations in the apparent number of people unemployed in terms of claiming benefits. But regardless of the action that should be taken, it is important to be able to analyse economies – especially those of developing countries – so that we can compare and contrast. The unemployment rate in its current form does nothing to help this.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Putin, driving an economy to destruction

 

Putin enjoying his spare time

The last year has been a show of strength by the all-powerful Putin government. It has held power, clamped down on its media and successfully annexed part of Ukraine whilst still giving its President the time to undertake a variety of bareback activities. However one thing that Russia has not been able to keep hold of is it’s free market valuation, which has performed dreadfully over the past weeks with the rouble losing 40% of its value. Unfortunately for him, this is entirely of Putin’s own making. Russia’s recent economic form comes from his policies, aggression and the widespread corruption which runs through his government.

 

A very different ball game

It was barely over 70 years ago that Russia undertook a similar task to the one they attempted this year, albeit in a more brazen manner. During 1944 the Soviet Union successfully invaded 4 eastern European countries, each invasion receiving its own justification. This year, to protect the Russian speaking peoples from the rest of the Ukrainian population, a large section of Eastern Ukraine has been successfully invaded by Russian forces. 70 years ago the invasions had little effect on the Russian economy which remained one of the strongest in the world for at least 20 years before economic stagnation set in (see article by Gregor Bates). This time the Russian economy has lasted barely a year before cracks start to show. The difference between the two situations (ignoring external global events) is how the Russian economy is set up. In 1944 the Russian economy was centrally planned and unified in its purpose allowing for very low rates of unemployment, high job security and most importantly a high level of self sufficiency. Since then Russia has developed many trade links throughout the world which are now vital for its sustained growth and corruption has seeped into its politics from the oil industry.

The oil crisis

Over the past year oil prices have plummeted by unprecedented amounts totaling roughly 30% of its value. This has had dire effects in Russia who’s exports are two thirds oil and gas meaning that aggregate demand and RNO in Russia have been hit hard. Russia’s dependence on oil has stemmed from the reluctance of its president to expand the countries other potential export areas like manufacturing and the high-tech industry. It’s clear that this is a result of the underlying corruption in Russia which creates a large bias towards rich oligarchs who seek to further their own wealth as opposed to their countries. This same corruption has meant that ordinary economic methods haven’t achieved any results. A recent rise in interest rates is the latest in a series of measures that haven’t worked to stabilize the economy. The uncontrollable nature of such a lawless economy and the instability of its recent actions is no doubt the reason that investors have shunned its currency. Moreover Putin’s friendships with his oligarch friends may well start to strain if he continues to implement policies which hurt their businesses. Should he lose their support, Putin’s economy would surely collapse.

What can Russia do?

In the short term, not much. As I Mentioned previously the unique nature of the Russian economy means that the usual short term economic methods won’t work to control the nosediving economy. However to salvage what they can, Russians need to cleanse their government of its corrupt ways, diversify their economy to brace them against economic shocks such as the oil crisis this year and preferably withdraw from Ukraine to gain back the confidence of western investors. By trying to follow in his predecessors’ footsteps Putin will cripple his country as its new found market economy crumbles in his wake.

 

 

 

 

Is the UK in an Economic Stagnation?

Economic stagnation is a period of prolonged slow economic growth, which is actually what the UK is experiencing at the moment. This is because UK’s economic growth has fluctuated below 1% and 0% over the last year. So why is the the UK’s GDP not growing!

Why is it in Stagnation and Okun’s Law?

okuns-law.gif

Okun’s Law is a very simple concept. The logic behind it is that the output of an economy depends on the amount of labour used in the production process, and hence more employed means more output. Furthermore, we know that total employment equals the labor force minus the unemployed, so there is a negative relationship between output and unemployment. In short it is simply the idea that the unemployment of an economy is linked (inversely) with the economy’s growth rate, so the economy will grow if unemployment is low.

So could the result of high unemployment be the cause of this stagnation in UK? Well unemployment in the UK at the moment stands at 1.96 Million, which is a relatively large figure in comparison with the previous unemployment levels between 1997 and 2008, which were about 1.5 million. In actual fact the UK’s yearly economic growth was generally a lot higher in those years, although it did fluctuate vastly at times between 1.5% and roughly 0.1%. There is clearly evidence to support this reasoning, but is it really possible that reduced economic stagnation occurred solely due to lower rates of unemployment?

The Big Picture 

Okun’s Law is useful but only to a certain extent. For example, while it has been studied it has been known to shift over time and has impacted by unusual things regarding economic climates, including jobless recoveries and the more recent financial crises. It also appears that relying on Okun’s law to make specific predictions about unemployment, given economic growth trends, doesn’t hold up that well. This is due to the vast complexity of the inputs and different time periods that can be used, whilst basic uncertainty that goes with running economic regressions can result in the law becoming quite complex. But even though it’s not always as accurate as it appears at first glance, it still shows great empirical evidence and it is very useful to show the relationship between the trend growth and unemployment.

So overall, while the UK is in stagnation it isn’t as serious as you may think. Technically, of course, the economy is still positive and therefore growing, but the fact it hasn’t been growing at a higher rate each year means it still is within the stagnation ‘threshold’ by definition. However, the lack of significant economic growth isn’t just due to post-recession unemployment in the UK. There are obviously a lot of other factors such as interest rates and real wages that come into play, so employment is merely a small factor but it is still interconnected with a few other ideas, like the theory that the only way full employment will be achieved is by negative interest rates – which is something best discussed at a later date!

What’s holding Africa back?

African countries GDP per capita compared to world average
African countries GDP per capita compared to world average

From the 1960’s to the present, multiple Asian economies such as China, Hong Kong, Singapore and India have mobilised their economies at rates far exceeding those of already developed countries spending long periods of time which growth levels above 7%. Why is it, then, that over this same period of time sub-Saharan Africa has experienced an average decline in per capita GDP of 11% taking into account for inflation?

There are many possible explanations for Africa’s poor growth and it’s likely that a combination of many of them will be causing these poor levels of growth. In this article I’m going to outline a few of those which I feel to be most prevalent.

World banks accredit the application of neoliberal policies to the Asian tiger’s growth through the late 20th century. This means they adopted rapid industrialisation and export-led economies to drive high levels of growth along with lowering taxes and reducing welfare states to minimise costs. However it would be unwise for African economies to attempt this same strategy.

For a start the costs of production in African countries make them uncompetitive in the world market, although rich in labour and land African countries lack the crucial capital and education that many of these “Asian tigers” already had before they started exporting. As an extension to this point many of these countries are losing out from their free market policies which mean that many of their internally produced goods are undercut by foreign goods that have been produced cheaper. This discourages the startup of firms (especially those in more advanced sectors that are crucial for later development) and increases the import component of AD which also stunts growth.

Another problem faced by African economies is that of their governments. Some people say that it’s a lack of knowledge here which is stopping growth but with increased globalisation it is unlikely that this is the case because other, smarter candidates from abroad would move to these countries as they would be likely to get the jobs from their less intelligent counterparts. Also, there is currently a lot of foreign aid available to these countries which does include financial advice (such as adopting a free market which, incidentally, benefits the countries likely to be providing the advice).

Instead I propose that it is the corruption and self seeking nature of those in power which causes these abysmal growth rates. For example in 2004 Shell oil inadvertently funded poverty and conflict just by operating in Nigeria due to the countries corrupt officials. The consequences of such corruption can lower growth both directly through things like the distribution of income being heavily weighted to the rich who will have lower marginal propensities to spend and also indirectly through the deterrence to foreign investment that it provides.

So there are many problems with Africa’s economies now, but what can be done to deal with them? Many of the solutions to these problems are difficult to implement and may well be contentious among established free market economies, however many of these solutions have been used before in previously underdeveloped, now developed countries.

To solve the problem of international competitiveness governments of these countries need to impose stricter regulations to help protect their small firms. For a start there needs to be heavy taxing of foreign goods that could potentially be produced within the country but can’t be produced right now as they don’t have the technology to compete with the foreign firms on price. Of course when I’m saying this I don’t mean that African governments should tax everything coming into their countries. It would be obtuse for an LEDC African country to tax imports of computers coming into its country in the hope that its country could start up firms designing computers, there simply isn’t the infrastructure or education in place for this to be possible. However some level of regulation is required to give its firms the advantages they desperately need. Over time this will hopefully give firms within these countries the funds necessary to improve capital and education in their sectors to an extent that they are internationally competitive and the import taxes are no longer required.

Having built up this capital and education these African countries could use the extra economic growth and education to expand into more advanced sectors like technology and telecoms which previously were out of their reach. This is what happened in the Asian tigers with companies like Samsung who started out in the 1930’s as a trading company in food processing and textiles during times when South Korea  had a GDP per capita of $79, lower than those of some sub-Saharan African countries. Then, through pressuring from its government and subsidies (also provided by the government) Samsung moved into technology. Now the biggest technology company in the world by revenue and South Korea’s largest company by the same measure, Samsung is a great example of how sub-Saharan African governments can bring their firms into the modern era.

The other solution is an obvious one, reducing the corruption imbedded in African governments will allow for the implementation of policies which will help boost growth such as higher minimum wages, subsidies, better wage distribution, more effective use of foreign aid and the increased investment from foreign firms that comes with a less corrupt and therefore more stable political system. Of course there are lots more positive side effects of taking out corruption in government but those were a few which related to earlier points in the post.

Unfortunately to actually reduce corruption is a difficult process. Many of the people who benefit from the corruption are rich, influential and may well have political connections overseas. Plus many of these nations have become war torn and violent, often as a result of this corruption, which means that trying to implement political change within them would be nigh impossible. Even if you were successful in removing corruption from one country the poor border control and volume of other corrupt countries surrounding each other would mean that corruption would be likely to return after a short period of time.

So what can be done? I don’t know the answer myself although I would suggest that some international pressure could be applied not just from international bodies (UN, EU etc.) but also from corporations which have a strong interest in the de-corruption. For example many of the countries in sub-Saharan Africa are natural resource rich with a lot of oil and minerals. However the raging conflict and low levels of infrastructure have prevented much of the resources available from being extracted. If major oil and mining companies put pressure on sub-Saharan governments, by carrot or by stick, then it may yield some results. This would bring further benefits as the companies could bring in extra infrastructure and capital along with more investment.

If corruption can be stopped in Sub-Saharan governments and the right policies can be  implemented subsequently then I strongly believe it would be the first step towards the rejuvenation and modernisation of this area of Africa. As it is now, sub-Saharan Africa will remain one of the least developed and most poverty stricken places on earth.

1% Inflation – Blessing or Blight for the UK Economy?

falling-oil-pricesIt was announced this morning that the Consumer Price Index here in the UK has fallen to just 1%, the lowest rate for more than a decade. This was instigated by a dramatic fall in the world price of oil, which slumped to $60 a barrel (Brent Oil) on Tuesday, and a fall in the average price of food. Mark Carney, Governor of the Bank of England, may shortly be writing to Downing Street to explain why inflation has significantly undercut the Bank’s 2% target rate, but is such a low interest rate positive or detrimental to the state of the UK economy?

Consumer Spending

Particularly during the home stretch towards Christmas, low inflation will likely cause a surge in consumer expenditure which would no doubt contribute to economic growth. Thanks to a fall in fuel costs, the average household will now experience a rise in disposable income that consumers will feel can be better spent on the festive period. Not only that, but low inflation in the UK means that the Bank of England will feel no obligation to raise the interest rates above the current 0.5%. Consequently, incentives to save will remain poor and consumers are more likely to spend rather than save. Perfect for the economy?

Speculation

Ideally, yes, but one significant drawback of low inflation takes the shape of speculative consumers. Not satisfied enough with the current fall in fuel and grocery prices, it is possible that many consumers might delay spending in an attempt to score better deals on goods. This could actually cause economic growth to stagnate due to reduced spending. However, in this scenario today it appears as if Christmas is here to save the day. Although consumers may be aware that prices could fall further, presents and such must be purchased prior to the December 25th deadline in order to avoid unhappy relatives, and so expenditure is unlikely to be slowed this December.

Expansion

In addition to potential short term economic growth, 1% inflation may also bring longer term benefits. With inflation and therefore interest rates so low, firms have a strong incentive to take out lower-cost loans needed to fuel expansion. It is possible that this could lead to an increase in long run aggregate supply (LRAS) and with that comes further productive capacity. Manufacturing firms will be pleased with the news of a fall in oil prices, as lower costs of production will make them more internationally competitive and profits could well increase. Despite that, the same cannot, of course, be said of oil corporations and companies who rely on a high price of oil to maintain profitability.

Overall, it seems as if low inflation will – at least temporarily – prove to be marginally beneficial for the UK economy as a whole, while joyous consumers can enjoy Christmas dinners that cost less than last year (even though a fall in real wage growth will still occur, albeit at the lowest rate in the last 5 years). However, concerns may begin to grow if inflationary pressures cease to increase in the coming months. Indeed, 13 countries in Europe are predicted to experience deflation at some point in the near future should oil prices fail to rise once more. Until then, we will just have to wait and see what impact this will have on the United Kingdom.